Go Back

Nothing vs. Phade 7.75" Jumbo Eco-Straws

Phade straws are marketed as eco-friendly because they're made from PHA, a bioplastic derived from canola oil. PHA is sold as breaking down just about anywhere, but real-world breakdown depends on specific conditions that most environments don't meet. Outside them, it can persist and shed microplastics, like other plastics.

Nothing straws are paper with a water-based coating. Plastic-free, biodegradable, and gone in 180 days or less, no special conditions required.

	Phade
Breaks down in 180 days, anywhere	Breakdown time is variable and condition-dependent
Soil Biodegradable	Soil Biodegradable
Marine Biodegradable	Marine biodegradable (but Phade says never dispose of it in the ocean)
Plastic-Free	Made from PHA, a plastic
Recyclable	Not Recyclable
Legal for food service in Montreal & BC	Banned for food service in Montreal & BC
Detailed Comparison
Nothing Products Paper Straw	Phade 7.75” Jumbo Eco-Straw
Marine biodegradable, full stop Paper breaks down in water with no caveats and no fine print.	"Marine biodegradable." With an asterisk Phade's 58-day ocean figure comes from a controlled lab, not the sea, and scientists say real-world breakdown is slower and varies by conditions. Phade's own packaging says never dispose of a straw in a marine environment, and Phade won't make the marine claim at all in California, Maryland, Minnesota, Oregon, or Washington.
Plastic-free Paper with a water-based coating, certified plastic-free by Flustix. No plastic lining.	Still plastic PHA is a bioplastic. It can't be recycled, and as a plastic it can fragment into microplastics.
Legal to serve anywhere Paper cups and straws are exempt from single-use bans.	Banned in Montreal and BC PHA is prohibited for restaurants and food service in Montreal and across British Columbia.